The Hidden Ripple Effects of Insight: How to Harness Your “Aha!” Moments for Innovation

In the third century BCE, the Greek mathematician and physicist Archimedes did something strange: he ran naked through the streets of Syracuse.

Let’s rewind. As the story goes, King Hiero II of Syracuse suspected he was being cheated. He had commissioned a golden votive crown, and he believed the goldsmith had replaced some of the gold with cheaper silver. He tasked Archimedes with determining whether the crown was pure gold without damaging it.

It seemed like an impossible problem. Archimedes knew the density of gold, but he didn’t know how to measure the crown’s volume without melting and reshaping it into a regular geometric form. For weeks, Archimedes wrestled with the problem, trying calculation after calculation.

Then one day, lowering himself into a bath, Archimedes watched the water level rise.

In that instant, he saw it. The volume of water displaced equaled the volume of his body submerged. And if that was true for his body, it was true for any object—including an irregular golden crown. He could measure the crown’s volume by measuring how much water it displaced, calculate its density, and thus determine its purity.

“Eureka!” he shouted. (Translation: “I have found it!”) And then he leapt from the bath and ran naked through the city streets, so consumed by the insight that he forgot he was unclothed.

This story has become the archetypal example of an “Aha!” moment—that sudden clarity when an answer unfolds in front of you. Apocryphal or not, the story demonstrates an important truth about insight: it can make us behave in unusual ways. 

Because insights don’t just give you answers. They create ripple effects that reshape your memory, your conviction, your judgment, and your willingness to act boldly. For innovators, understanding these ripple effects is the difference between having breakthroughs and actually building on them.

And the effects are more powerful—and more nuanced—than you might think.

The Memory Supercharge: How Insights Stick in Your Brain

First, let’s appreciate what your brain is doing for you. 

In a study led by Amory H. Danek, participants watched videos of magic tricks and had to explain how the tricks were done. A week later, when asked about the solutions, participants were better able to remember those solutions that they discovered by insight as opposed to analytical thinking. The study attributed this tendency to the certainty and emotional pleasure that accompanies insights.

In short: “aha!” moments stick in your brain more than solutions found by working through a problem methodically.

This isn’t just convenient—it's transformative. Think about what happens during innovation: you have a breakthrough about how to solve a technical challenge, then you need to hold on to that solution through weeks or months of implementation, team alignment, and iteration. Analytical solutions fade. Insights stick.

The Double-Edged Sword of Conviction: Certainty ≠ Truth

Here's where insight becomes even more interesting—and where understanding its mechanics helps you use it more effectively.

As we unpacked in our last post, insight comes bundled with certainty. You don’t just understand the solution—you know it’s right. You feel it in your bones. This conviction is precisely what gives innovators the courage to pursue breakthrough ideas that others dismiss as impossible.

But that feeling of certainty doesn’t perfectly correlate with correctness.

In Maxi Becker’s study examining insight using Mooney images—black-and-white pictures that suddenly resolve into recognizable objects—participants wrongly identified more than half of the images they saw. Yet in those incorrect instances, they still reported experiencing insight 40 percent of the time. In comparison, in correct trials, they felt insight 65 percent of the time.

Notice what this tells you: insight is more likely to accompany correct solutions than incorrect ones. The certainty you feel is a genuine signal, not just noise. But it’s not a perfect signal—think of it as a probability indicator rather than a guarantee.

For innovators, this means you can and should follow your insights, with an important caveat:  an insight is a hypothesis, so you can’t trust it blindly; you must test it. 

A Paradox of Judgment: The Halo Effect and “Bullshit Receptivity”

Here’s where things get even more interesting. An “aha!” feeling can affect your beliefs about not just the insight itself but about other, even completely unrelated ideas.

In a study led by Ruben Laukkonen, researchers paired statements with anagrams to be solved. When participants solved an anagram by insight rather than analysis, they found the accompanying statement—which had nothing to do with the anagram—to be more believable, even when it was false. This suggests that “aha!” moments can cast a halo of certainty around other ideas occurring in the same “temporal neighborhood.”

This might not be a bad thing. Your brain, riding the high of one breakthrough, becomes more open to the next idea that follows. Imagine you’re pitching your innovation and trigger a feeling of insight in your audience. That will create momentum for the broader conversation.

The dark side, though, is that you can be tricked into believing falsehoods. So you must question your certainty of both the core insight and the domino effect of certainties that follow.

However, there’s also a paradox here. Research led by Carola Salvi found that people who relied more heavily on insight when solving puzzles were better at distinguishing between real and fake news, and between meaningful statements and pseudo-profound nonsense. She calls this reduced “bullshit receptivity.”

So while an individual insight might cast a halo of false certainty, in the macro picture, people who experience and rely on insight have better BS detectors. Ultimately, insights can both improve and cloud your judgment, so be prepared to test your assumptions.

The Courage Factor: How Insight Fuels Bold Decisions

Perhaps as a result of this halo of certainty, there’s another interesting side effect of “aha!” moments: they increase tolerance to risk. 

In another study, Becker examined this effect by having participants solve Mooney images and then choose between monetary payouts. After solving a puzzle with high insight, participants were more likely to select riskier, higher-reward options. Corresponding brain imaging showed enhanced activity in the nucleus accumbens—a region linked to reward processing and dopamine release, which influences how emotions translate into action.

In other words, insight doesn’t just change what you think. It changes what you’re willing to bet.

The greatest innovations in history required people to make bold bets that looked foolish at the time. Risk is not a bad thing, but recklessness is. The difference between a smart risk and a reckless bet is the same difference between confidence and arrogance. Confidence is built through the acquisition of knowledge, understanding, and wisdom. Arrogance is unearned and untested.

Use the confidence boost that insight provides to push yourself into action, but recognize that whether you continue on that path of innovation is a question you must continually ask yourself. As you gain more knowledge, you may decide to go double or nothing, or to fold and pivot. 

Mastering the Insight Advantage

Insights are powerful precisely because they change you. They let you see what others miss, help you remember what matters, generate conviction that fuels persistence, and muster the courage to act.

These aren't bugs in the system—they’re features. They’re exactly what you need to do innovative work.

But certainty is an anathema to innovation, so you must be cognizant of what is happening in your brain after an insight. Don’t fall into the trap of false certainty. Insights are still just hypotheses until you put them through a rigorous process of testing.

Think of it this way: Insight gives you the courage to make bold bets. Validation helps you make smart ones.

‍